Could a planet really survive the 3 Body Problem’s three suns? We simulated 60 of them
Source: Science News, Carleton University / The Conversation, NASA, NASA, NASA
Netflix’s 3 Body Problem, based on Liu Cixin’s novel, imagines an alien world in a system of three stars about four light-years from Earth. Its people live through calm “stable eras” and deadly “chaotic eras” as their three suns wander unpredictably across the sky. It is science fiction, but the problem in the title is real physics, and one of the oldest unsolved puzzles in astronomy. So we asked a simple question: could a planet actually survive there?
WHAT IS THE THREE-BODY PROBLEM? With two objects, such as a star and a planet, gravity is completely predictable. Isaac Newton solved it: each follows a neat, repeating orbit, which is why we can predict the Moon’s position years ahead. Add a third object of similar mass and that predictability falls apart. There is no general formula that gives the future positions of three bodies, only a few special cases, such as three equal masses chasing each other round a figure of eight. Most three-body systems are chaotic: a tiny change in where things start leads to a completely different outcome later on. You can still calculate the motion step by step with a computer, but small uncertainties grow until long-range prediction becomes impossible, a bit like the weather.
WE RAN THE SIMULATION. To test the show’s premise, we built our own simulation using Newton’s law of gravity. Each run had three stars between 0.9 and 1.1 times the mass of the Sun, starting a few times the Earth–Sun distance apart and moving in random directions, but bound together by their own gravity. Each one had an Earth-like planet starting in an Earth-like orbit around one of the stars. We kept it in two dimensions to make it easier to show, used a high-precision calculation that conserved the system’s energy to within a hundredth of a percent, and let each system run for up to 300 years.
THE RESULT: NOT ONE PLANET SURVIVED. In all 60 systems, the planet was lost. In 59 it was flung out of the system altogether, and in one it fell into a star. Half of the planets were gone within about 23 years, and 59 of the 60 within a century. The longest-lasting held on for 181 years, an eye-blink in astronomical terms.
Our video shows one of those 60 runs. The planet starts in a comfortable orbit, then gets passed between the suns about ten times. Each close pass to a star scorches it, and each time it swings out into the dark between them it freezes: its rough temperature swings between about 290 °C and minus 200 °C. There are even brief calm spells when it settles around one star, the show’s “stable eras”, before the next encounter breaks them up. Around year 22, two of the suns pair up and the third is thrown out of the system, dragging the planet away with it.
The temperatures in our simulation are rough estimates from starlight alone, and a real planet with air and oceans would be gentler. But no atmosphere can survive being flung between three suns for long, and none can stop the planet being thrown out. The cosmologist Jacques Delabrouille, of France’s CNRS research centre, told Science News much the same thing about the show’s world: in a truly chaotic system, the planet would either fall into one of the stars or be ejected.
SO HOW DO REAL PLANETS LIVE WITH MORE THAN ONE STAR? By keeping things tidy. Planets in multi-star systems survive when the system has a clear hierarchy, either because the stars are far apart or because two of them are very close together. In the first case, the planet hugs one star and the others are distant enough not to disturb it. Astronomers call that an S-type orbit. In the second, the planet circles a tight pair of stars from far outside, as if they were one: a P-type, or circumbinary, orbit. NASA’s Kepler telescope found the first confirmed example in 2011. Kepler-16 b, about 245 light-years away, is a Saturn-sized gas giant whose year lasts 229 days, and it sees two suns in its sky, like Tatooine in Star Wars.
THE REAL ALPHA CENTAURI IS CALM. The show’s three-star system is about four light-years away, just like the real Alpha Centauri, our nearest neighbour. But the real one is nothing like as chaotic. Two Sun-like stars, Alpha Centauri A and B, circle each other every 80 years. The third, the small red dwarf Proxima Centauri, is so far away, roughly 13,000 times the Earth–Sun distance, that it takes more than half a million years to orbit the other two. That is the kind of tidy arrangement that lets planets last.
And it has planets. Proxima b, a planet a little more massive than Earth, orbits Proxima every 11 days in that star’s habitable zone, where liquid water could exist on the surface, although Proxima’s violent flares may have stripped away any atmosphere. NASA says there may be two more planets around Proxima. In 2025, the James Webb Space Telescope also found evidence of a possible gas giant, roughly the mass of Saturn, orbiting Alpha Centauri A. When the team modelled it, they only considered orbits that would stay stable alongside star B. It has not been confirmed yet: later Webb observations did not spot it.
The second half of our video shows a simplified version of that kind of system: two Sun-like stars on an 80-year orbit, and a planet close to the bigger one. Orbit after orbit, it stays put and its temperature barely changes. The difference from the chaos above is all about distance.
THE VERDICT. A planet in a system of three similar stars all swinging around each other would not get stable and chaotic eras for thousands of years. It would most likely be gone within a human lifetime. The real universe is full of multi-star systems with planets, but they survive by keeping their distance, and the nearest one of all is right next door. You can find Alpha Centauri, including its three stars, in the free 099c Observatory at observatory.099c.co.uk, under Stellar Neighbourhood.
About our simulation: it uses Newton’s law of gravity for the three stars and treats the planet as too small to pull on them. It is two-dimensional and does not include the stars’ size or tides, so it is a demonstration, not a research result. A full three-dimensional version would not rescue the planet: chaos is chaos in any number of dimensions.

