Space

Barnard’s Star and its four planets: the full story, including the ones that turned out to be wrong

Source: NASA, NASA Exoplanet Archive, AAS Nova, University of Texas at Austin, arXiv (Basant et al. 2025)

Footage: 099c Observatory (NASA Exoplanet Archive data; sizes exaggerated, orbits sped up)

Barnard’s Star is the closest single star to the Sun, about 6 light-years away. Only the three stars of Alpha Centauri are nearer. In March 2025, astronomers confirmed that it has four small planets. Here is a closer look at the star, each planet in turn, and the long history of planets around it that turned out not to be real.

THE STAR. Barnard’s Star is a red dwarf, a type M4 star: much smaller, cooler and dimmer than the Sun. It has about 16% of the Sun’s mass and is roughly a fifth of its width. Its surface is about 2,900 °C, compared with about 5,500 °C for the Sun, and it gives out only about a third of one percent of the Sun’s light. It is very old, around 10 billion years, more than twice the age of the Sun. It was found in 1916 by the American astronomer Edward Emerson Barnard, and it moves across our sky faster than any other star: about the width of the full Moon every 175 years.

HOW THE PLANETS WERE FOUND. None of the four planets has been seen directly, and none passes in front of its star from our point of view. They were found by the radial velocity method: as each planet orbits, its gravity tugs the star very slightly towards and away from us, and that shifts the colour of the star’s light. NASA says the planets’ signals are only about 0.2 to 0.5 metres per second, while the star’s own surface noise is about 2 metres per second, nearly ten times larger. This method gives each planet’s minimum mass, which is why the masses below say “at least”. Their sizes are not measured.

Barnard b was announced in 2024 by a team using the ESPRESSO instrument on the Very Large Telescope in Chile. In March 2025, a team led by Ritvik Basant of the University of Chicago used the MAROON-X instrument on the Gemini North telescope in Hawaii, combined with the ESPRESSO data, to confirm b and three more planets: c, d and e. Their paper was published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters.

THE FOUR PLANETS, FROM THE INSIDE OUT. The figures below come from the 2025 study, as listed in NASA’s Exoplanet Archive. The temperatures are rough estimates of how hot each planet would be from starlight alone, not measurements.

Barnard d is the innermost planet. It goes round the star once every 2.34 days, at less than a fiftieth of the Earth–Sun distance. It is at least 0.26 times the mass of Earth, with an estimated temperature of about 210 °C.

Barnard b orbits every 3.15 days and is at least 0.30 times Earth’s mass, with an estimated temperature of about 165 °C. It was the first of the four to be found.

Barnard c orbits every 4.12 days. At least 0.34 times Earth’s mass, it is the heaviest of the four, with an estimated temperature of about 127 °C.

Barnard e is the outermost, with a year of 6.74 days. At no less than 0.19 times Earth’s mass, it is one of the lightest planets ever found with the radial velocity method. Its estimated temperature is about 67 °C.

COULD ANY OF THEM SUPPORT LIFE? Almost certainly not. A habitable zone is the range of distances where a planet could, in principle, have liquid water on its surface. Because Barnard’s Star is so dim, its habitable zone is very close in: planets there would have years of roughly 10 to 42 days. All four planets orbit inside that, in under a week each, so they are too hot. NASA describes them as orbiting “much too closely to be habitable”. The 2025 study also rules out any planet in the habitable zone heavier than about 0.57 Earth masses. A smaller planet there has not been ruled out, so the search is not quite over.

WHY THE LETTERS ARE IN THAT ORDER. Planets are named after their star, with a lower-case letter in the order they are announced, starting at b. The star itself counts as “A”. The letters have nothing to do with distance, which is why the order from the star outwards is d, b, c, e. Barnard b came first, in 2024, so it got b. Then c, d and e were added together in 2025. There are no missing letters at Barnard’s Star, but there is a reused one, and that is where the history comes in.

THE PLANETS THAT WEREN’T. NASA calls Barnard’s Star “notorious among astronomers for a history of false planet detections”. In the 1960s, the Dutch-American astronomer Peter van de Kamp reported a wobble in the star’s position, and later claimed two giant planets. Other astronomers could not confirm them, and the wobble was traced to changes made to the telescope he was using. Then in 2018, an international team announced a “super-Earth”: a planet several times Earth’s mass on a 233-day orbit, known at the time as Barnard’s Star b. In 2021, a team led by Jack Lubin of the University of California, Irvine showed that the signal more likely came from the star’s own activity. The star spins once every 145 days or so, and that rotation, seen through the yearly cycle of observations, mimicked a planet.

Because that 2018 planet was withdrawn, its letter was free, and the real planet found in 2024 became the new Barnard b. So the name Barnard b has been given to two different planets, only one of which exists. That is also why the 2025 confirmation mattered so much: after decades of false alarms, independent instruments on two telescopes finally agreed.

SEE IT YOURSELF. Our footage was filmed in the free 099c Observatory, which uses the same NASA Exoplanet Archive figures. The green ring is the modelled habitable zone, and all four planets sit inside it. Planet sizes are exaggerated so you can see them, and the orbits are sped up. To find it, open observatory.099c.co.uk, go to Stellar Neighbourhood, choose Barnard’s Star, then Orbit map and Star view.

More in this section